NORTH SHORE REGIONAL COLLEGE STUDY tantalus research limited Dr. Walter G. Hardwick Prof. Ronald J. Baker 1965 NORTH SHORE REGIONAL COLLEGE STUDY tantalus research limited SEPTEMBER, 1965 Dr. Walter G. Hardwick UNIVERSITY OF BRITISH COLUMBIA Prof. Ronald J. Baker SIMON FRASER UNIVERSITY RESEARCH ASSOCIATES E.M.W. Gibson, M.A. J. R. Wolforth, B. Sc., M.A. R. Leigh, B.Sc(Econ), M.A. H. S. Swain, B. A. Tantalus Research Limited Publisher - Vancouver, Canada Tantalus Research Limited 741 WEST 26th AVENUE, TELEPHONE B.C. 9, VANCOUVER September 1st, 1965 'I' Secretary-Treasurer, North Vancouver School District #44, 721 Chesterfield, North Vancouver, B. C. Secretary-Treasurer, West Vancouver School District #45, 1 7 35 Inglewood, West Vancouver, B. C. Dear Sirs: We wish to present for your consideration the NORTH SH ORE REGIONAL COLLEGE STUDY, commissioned in December 1964 by the Boards of School Trustees of School Districts #44 (North Vancouver) and #45 (West Vancouver). We were pleased to bring together the talents of Dr. Walter G. Hardwick, Professor Ronald J. Baker and the team of research associates, who produced this report. This submission has been designed to answer the specific questions that prompted the School Boards to initiate the study. In addition it will provide pertinent general information regarding the present structure of the North Shore Community. Yours very truly, ,;'i' "\lif/; ' ;(,· /'' /' � I ,. . ., /-t-adening appreciation for e mother usually has the • be demonstrated that modifications in priorities set out in his report are clearly ., Secondly, the new Secondary curriculum instituted by the Department of Education since the report contains implications for post secondary education which could not indicated by a more refined analysis of population numbers and characteristics. have been foreseen at the time the Report was written. 1munity college might be ;posable income, already d trend, more and more 1. t i m e activity in its own ctivity. However, on the basis of our analysis we believe there are sound g r o u n d s for the i m m e d i a t e reconsideration of some of the conclusions of his Report. F i r s t 1 y , a review of the assumptions upon which the college priorities were assigned reveals that only gross data were considered. In particular it can This function is A critical review of the Macdonald Report In Higher Education 1n British Columbia,,:, u s u a 11 y c a 11 e d t h e Macdonald Report, Dr. J.B. Macdonald argued that the p r o v i n c e should set up a series of ,grams in the schools and it has been noted in the )f people have university t w o - y e a r colleges. t desired, particularly in from the large number of raduation and immersion advanced training for those students who have the necessary ability and aptitude; education: 1. "I see the need for two basic kinds of institutions of higher Un i v e r s i t i e s and 4-year colleges offering degree programs and 2. 2-year colleges offering a variety of programs of one or two years of education • , • beyond Grade 12. 11 education missed in their ager points to the econ­ "Although I expect 2-year colleges to differ from one another in accordance tan or woman who through in the ranks of the do-it­ ng degree not only hobby with local needs, I believe that the d i f f e r e n c e s will exist m a i n 1 y in the non­ academic areas of their work. Such institutions could attract very a b 1 e students and professors by offering courses and facilities of distinctive character: Seminar md a whole wide range of education, small classes, interdisciplinary studies, close personal contact between prof�ssors and students, p r o m o t i o n b a s e d principally on accomplishments in teaching, and so forth". ut not less important, is ultural as well as for the .ar activities as amateur c h t h e community as a 1n of community and civic the Greek agora and the :as, the physical catalyst ., To combine the ideal of providing suitable higher education for all students who can benefit from it with the ideal of e qu a 1 i t y of opportunity for all students throughout the province wherever possible, p r o v i s i o n m u s t be made in 2-year colleges for those students who want to transfer to a 4-year college or a university later on. A 2-year college, therefore, might be designed for those students who plan to continue their education at a degree-granting institution; those who wish to take only one or two years of higher education - technical, academic, or a com­ bination of both; those who are undecided about their educational futures; those who are u n d e c i d e d about their educational futures; those who by preference or for financial reasons wish to remain in their own locality. 1gust 30, 1965, p. 67 -70. st. >:< J. B, Macdonald, H i g h e r E d u c a t i o n m British Columbia and a Plan for the Future, Vancouver, 1962, -14Although each of these two-year colleges would have to design its program to meet the requirements_ of the area in which it is located, the objectives of 2-year colleges might include one or more of the following: (i) 2-year academic program for students who will either transfer to degree-granting institutions or will com­ plete their formal education at this level; (ii) technological and semi-professional courses designed for students who want formal education beyond secondary school but do not plan to c o m p 1 e t e the requirements for a degree; (iii) adult education including r e - e d u c a t i o n to meet the changing demands of technical and semi­ professional occupations. President Macdonald also made a specific recommendation for the Greater Vancouver area, namely, that there should be one two-year college serving all the municipalities. He predicted that in 1965-66 such a college might enroll 900 to 1, 000 students in first year and 540 in second year. rather than in technolo lum offered in a comp the possibilities of trac and with those of sub-1 people for the areas wl more jobs. In a d v a n demands great flexibL is no longer possible b a highly s p e c i a 1 i z e expect that most peopl, working world . ... (c) The King Edward Cont couver City College, b students from outside proposal is no longer the Vancouver City Co: indicates that one coll that most of the advan1 (d) It is n o w p r o p o s e present Langara Golf Shore. (e) As the survey makes c children should recei, area - a fact that wa: metropolitan area. Tl on the North Shore tha (f) Similarly, it is now c and in particular in tl from area to area. A1 predicted for the whol, (g) The steady increase iI avenues to higher educ about their academic i (h) A 1 t h o u g h Dr. Macd granting institution in tional academic subje Fraser University wo, dents who were u n al: Columbia or the UnivE that the standards den are fundamentally the it could be a Universi S i n c e 1 9 6 3 , however, a number of developments have occurred that make necessary a reconsideration of Dr. Macdonald's proposals: (a) (b) ,:, It has become abundantly clear from the experience of incipient Vancouver City College that the public demand for a comprehensive community college (put forward in a number of briefs to Dr. Macdonald) h a s b e e n j u s t i f i e d . Whereas the Macdonald Report assumed that the two-year college would be fundamentally concerned with students with q u a l i f i c a t i o n s for university entrance, the Vancouver College, operating under the name of the King Edward Continuing Education Centre, discovered that there were a very large number of adult students anxious to obtain university entrance standards who were not catered for in the t r a d i t i o n a 1 night school program. Many of them were anxious to attend college during the day. Moreover, other students who had partial university entrance were a n x i o u s to complete it and continue. The enrollment figures for the King Edward Center in 1964-65, at which time it was giving only pre-university work and first year work, were a s f o 11 o w s : 900 in Grade 13, and an additional 700 on secondary completion programs and partial Grade 13. N e a r 1 y 9, 000 people attended late-afternoon and evening courses. The demand for education as revealed above has a 1 s o b e e n j u s t i f i e d in a number of p u b 1 i c a t i o n s relating facilities in higher education to economic growth,,:, It is increasingly well documented that an advanced society such as our own develops more and more jobs in the so-called tertiary occupations, For e x a m p l e , see: F. Harbison and C.A. Myer, Education, Manpower and Economic Growth, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1964; J. J. Stone, "Education and the Upper Midwest Economies", Upper Midwest Economic Study, T e c h n i c a l Paper No, 9, 1964; and E. F, Denison, The sources of Economic Growth in the Committee f o r E c o n o m i c United States and the Alternatives Before Us,' Development, 1962. .. c -15- to design its program to the objectives of 2-year -year academic program Lnstitutions or will com1 and semi-professional >eyond secondary school :ee; ( iii) adult education of technical and semi- :ndation for the Greater ,r college serving all the lege might enroll 900 to rather than in technological occupations. · In other words, the kind of curricu­ lum offered in a comprehensive community college, a curriculum combining the possibilities of traditional academic work with those of liberal education, and with those of sub-professional training, is p a r t i c u 1 a r 1 y suited to train people for the areas where most jobs are available - jobs which in turn create more jobs. In a d v a n c e d societies the rapidity of technological change also demands great flexibility in both the educational system and its students. It is no longer possible to provide a rigid academic program on the one hand, or a highly s p e c i a 1 i ze d technical or technological program on the other, and expect that most people will thereby be fitted for the rapidity of change in the working world. .,. (c) The King Edward Continuing Education Centre has d e v e 1 o p e d into the Van­ couver City College, but it has a number of restrictions on the attendance of students from outside the City of Vancouver. Consequently, Dr. Macdonald's proposal is no longer feasible. Even if it were politically possible to make the Vancouver City College available to all students, its enrollment in 1964-65 indicates that one college is no longer enough, unless it were to be so large that most of the advantages of the community college would be given up. (d) It is n o w p r o p o s e d that the Vancouver City College will be located on the present Langara Golf Course, a site relatively inaccessible from the North Shore. (e) As the survey makes clear, (map 4), the e x p e c t a t i o n of parents that their children should receive some college education varies widely from area to area - a fact that was not considered in Dr. Macdonald I s proposals for the metropolitan area. The expectation of higher education is considerably higher on the North Shore than in other parts of the metropolitan area. (f) Similarly, it is now clear that the retention of students in secondary school, and in particular in the academic programs in the secondary school, varies from area to area. Again, r e t e n t i o n is higher on the North Shore than was predicted for the whole area. (g) The steady increase in university fees has made it necessary to provide other avenues to higher education, especially for those students who are undecided about their academic interests or ability. (h) A l t h o u g h Dr. Macdonald's report clearly recommended that a new degree­ granting institution in the Burnaby area should offer the more or less tradi­ tional academic subjects, it is certain that many people thought that Simon Fraser University would in fact provide avenues to higher education for stu­ dents who were u n a b l e to obtain a d m i s s i o n to the University of British Columbia or the University of Victoria. It is now abundantly clear, however, that the standards demanded and the admission requirements at Simon Fraser are fundamentally the same as those at U. B. C. In fact, it is hard to see how it could be a University if this were not so. Even if, as many people believe, tave occurred that make ,. of incipient Vancouver 1.sive community college has been justified. o-year college would be Lc a t i o n s for university name of the King Edward ere a very large number i standards who were not tm. Many of them were other students who had ete it and continue. The 964-65, at which time it Hk, were a s f o l l o w s: :ompletion programs and te-afternoon and evening i ::> b e e n j u s t i f i e d in a er education to economic advanced society such as . led tertiary occupations, :ducation, Manpower and J. Stone, "Education and mic Study, T e c h n i c a l Economic Growth in the mittee f o r E c o n o m i c .. -16- extend its educational Simon Fraser is flexible in its admission policies, it is still fundamentally resources for all who c concerned with the traditional Arts and Sciences, It appears that it is likely to solve the problem which led to Dr. Macdonald I s recommend ation that it be set noon and evening cour i credit seminars, insti1 up, namely, that of taking the pressure of numbers from U. B. C. It is also clear that it will not serve as a community college in the sense in which com­ professional and occup est, and so forth". munity colleges are understood elsewhere. I n f a c t , were Simon Fraser to satisfy some of the demand for community colleges, it would clearly be failing in its goal as envisaged by Dr. Macdonald. (i) Similarly the B. C. Institute of Technology, initiated by the provincial govern­ ment before the Macdonald Report was published, has proved to be an invalu­ able addition to the spectrum of institutions of higher education in the province. However, our need for it and its success do not mean that we do not need less specialized institutions. ... .. We need technologists very badly, but we need a con­ commitant, and p e r h a p s even larger, increase in training for people in the The 1965, clearly accepts the implication of a wider function for the two­ year college than the enrollment predictions in the Macdonald Report indicate. The pamphlet points out that "some students who do not meet the s t i p u l a t e d The admirable and unp acted on the Macdonald Rei requirements for entrance to a university may, by successfully completing a college academic program, prove their suitability for continuing their educat­ ities in higher education to It also says that "students who transfer from one college of the two-year college. program to another would be r e q u i r e d to make up any deficiencies in their secondary school subjects by taking college pre-requisite courses. Such pre­ requisite courses should not duplicate those of the secondary school curricu­ lum; they should be more intensive, cover a wider scope and progress more rapidly than those at the Grade 12 level 11• It 2. g o e s o n t o say that "because study", In other words, the Academic Board implies that students may well go on to a community college from secondary school programs other than those traditionally leading to university. If the present reorganization of the second­ ary school system is s u c c e s s f u 1, the number of students taking the purely academic program leading to university entrance should drop relative to the total number of high school students. There is no reason to doubt, however, that many students who in the past would have taken university entrance pro­ grams, but who in the future will take one of the other possibilities, deserve, and will profit from, post-secondary education. (k) The Academic B o a r d also pointed out in its pamphlet that the two-year colleges should meet the "broad educational demands of the communities they serve". It maintains that "a college should reach out into the community to Implications of the Ne, Students entering Grad college courses are required by statute to be at a post secondary school level, there is a clear distinction between college technical programs and those given in vocational schools. Some of the courses in a college may be in fields that a r e s i m i 1a r t o s o m e in a vocational school, but they will be at a more advanced level, and will include s u b j e c t s that encompass border fields of in the Macdonald Report ar cater to the student who ha, statement of the purpose of City College demonstrated partial-college training on adult students. Columbia System of Higher Education", published by the Academic Board in ion at a university". Secondl' beyond the prescience of ar. college as being in adult ed p a m p h l e t "The Role of District and Regional Colleges in the British January, it was published. clearly shows that Dr. Ma, programs as desirable, ar. service industries, (j) To point to the above :r 1s not to criticize his repo: present study were both in, six new and distinctive pro, grams are most popular an gram in a special disciplin .. as the Community Service and S p e c i a l programs m widely accepted. Mr. Dea Resources II in Inventory of warning that large expendi1 the new programs will be Clearly the cor initiated. will offer students a chanc in programs that satisfy t n a r r o w exclusively acadt college students, -17extend its educational scope and to make use of the college's f a c i 1 i t i e s and resources for all who can benefit. Such programs usually include: late after­ noon and evening courses for credit in the v a r i o u s college programs; non­ credit seminars, institutes, workshops and conferences for persons in various professional and occupational fields; lecture series on topics of current interest, and so forth". it is still fundamentally appears that it is likely to immend ation that it be set 3 from U. B. C. It is also L the sense in which com­ t , were Simon Fraser to it would clearly be failing by the provincial governLS proved to be an invalu­ education in the province. .n that we do not need less badly, but we need a con­ training for people in the al Colleges in the British )Y the Academic Board in 111ider function for the twov1acdonald Report indicate. not meet the s t i p u 1 a t e d successfully completing a r continuing their educat­ transfer from one college 1 any deficiencies in their 1isite courses. Such pre­ ,econdary school curricu­ scope and progress more o n t o say that "because st secondary school level, . programs and those given lege may be in fields that mt they will be at a more Lcompass border fields of ; that students may well go )rograms other than those >rganization of the second­ students taking the purely hould drop relative to the reason to doubt, however, L university entrance pro­ ter possibilities, deserve, amphlet that the two-year s of the communities they )Ut into the community to ., To point to the above reasons for a reconsideration of Dr. Macdonald's plans 1s not to criticize his report. In the f i r s t p 1 a c e , the principal authors of this present study were both involved in its preparation and strongly supported it when it was published. Secondly, a number of the points made above are quite clearly beyond the prescience of anyone writing in 1962. The enrollment predictions given in the Macdonald Report are based on the assumption that two-year colleges would cater to the student who had achieved university entrance standing. However, the statement of the purpose of the two-year college, which we quoted on page l 3quite clearly shows that Dr. Macdonald saw some extension of the traditional academic programs as desirable, and also saw an important part of the work of a two-year college as being in adult education. What was impossible to see until the Vancouver City College demonstrated it, was the e x t e n t of the demand for pre -college and partial-college training on a f u l l - t i m e basis during regular day-time hours by adult students. The admirable and unprecedented speed with which the Provincial Government acted on the Macdonald Report has already demonstrated the need to extend facil­ ities in higher education to match the implications in Dr. Macdonald's description of the two-year college. 2. Implications of the New Secondary School Curriculum Students entering Grade 10 are now required to select a course of study from six new and distinctive programs. As in the past the academic and technical pro­ grams are most popular and will normally lead students toward a university pro­ gram in a special discipline or to the B. C. Institute of Technology. Others, such as the Community Service, Visual and Performing Arts, Commercial, Industrial and S p e c i a 1 programs must 1 e a d towards the regional college if they are to be widely accepted. Mr. Dean H. Goard in "People, Education, Labour and Natural Resources II in Inventory of Natural Resources of British Columbia ( 1964) sounds a warning that large expenditures in training teachers and equipping classrooms for the new programs will be wasted unless some p o s t - s e c o n d a r y programs are initiated. Clearly the comprehensive regional college envisioned in this report will offer students a chance for college training as well as a chance to specialize in programs that satisfy the range of talents and abilities of the population. The n a r r o w exclus ively academic programs are not appropriate for the majority of college students. 3. The College Population Pool -18- schools and classrooms r of central and western art pared for this study showi the predicted distribution by 1980. It indicates that in West Vancouver will 1 expected to move into the there is no indication wh Outdoor Recreation Resot ion of p o p u 1 a t i o n in W distribution is only appr, likely to remain the f a v c mobile. A comparison of pattern is expected to shi: In predicting the enrollment for a Regional College three stages of analysis a r e n e c e s s a r y : ( 1) predicting the number of 18-year olds, ( 2) determining the propensities for higher education, and ( 3) estimating the pull of existing institut­ ions. Growth in School Populations. Both of the North Shore School Districts have recorded sharp annual increases in school population. A c c o r d i n g to enrollment statistics supplied by the Boards,,:, growth rates at different levels and in different areas show distinct variations. In North Vancouver since 1961, nearly all the growth can be accounted for by: (a) (b) an increase in the size of the Grade 1 group, and a greater retention of s_tudents in the high schools. Eighteen-year-olds n fore, in predicting colle� population is used as a ba class is expressed as a p prepared for Dr. Macdon per cent of eight-year-ol those in western Fraser Some of the freshmen ma through school while othe Nevertheless the propens In the i n t e r m e d i a t e grades, groups moving from grade to grade show only mode st f l u c t u a t i o n s (See Table 1). Increases at intermediate levels in North Vancouver are rarely over 1 per cent per year. The explanation of this pattern lies in the nature of the families who are immigrating to North Vancouver. Generally, they are very young families who are purchasing their first houses and who intend to stay in their relatively inexpensive subdivision homes for several years. This hypothesis is supported by the answers given to the questions in recent and planned movements on the questionnaire. I n c o n t r a s t , West Vancouver's classes grow as they move up through the grades, increasing most rapidly in the intermediate and secondary years. As one official noted in conversation, "West Vancouver is the only school district in B. C. with 115 per cent retention through high school. 11 This seeming paradox indicates one of the major differences between North and West Vancouver. A home in West Vancouver is a favoured destination for the family that has already established an equity elsewhere. It takes considerably more money to move into West Vancouver; consequently, families are older. The influx is noted in the schools in the form of sharp inflows of students in the senior grades. It should be noted that this trend seems to be taking shape in the northwestern areas of North Vancouver also. Reports of the North Vancouver District Planning Office for the School Board':":' assess the population growth that can be expected in the next decade. In West Van­ couver, studies are currently underway to predict the increases in the number of North Vancouver School Board meeting, 26 October, 1964; West V a n c o u v e r School Board meeting, 9 November, 1964. ....,,.... ....,,.... School Report, 1962-63, Part I: The Western Areas, and Part II: The Eastern Areas. A l s o t h e r e p o r t , Prospects for Growth 1963 by the Planning and Property Department of the District of North Vancouver, deals specifically with this topic. :::: The eighteen-year-o jected from students in I Vancouver are estimated while rates for West Vani grade level. There is lit growth between school d: growth depending upon cb - N e a r 1 y 2, 000 eight 2, 400 in 1972; and nearly -19schools and classrooms required to meet anticipated growth in the upper sections of central and western areas. From these reports, a map (Figure 5) has been pre­ pared for this study showing the actual distribution of Grade 1 children in 1965 and three stages of analysis · olds, (2) determining the the predicted distribution for an "ultimate" population level, perhaps to be attained by 1980. It indicates that several areas along and above the Upper Levels Highway e pull of existing institut- in West Vancouver will be occupied, whereas substantially greater numbers are expected to move into the e a s t e r n s e c t i o n s of North Vancouver. At this date .ore School Districts have . c c o r d i n g to enrollment ·ent levels and in different h can be accounted for by: .. there is no indication whether the proposed Cypress Bowl development by Alpine Outdoor Recreation Resources Ltd. will have appreciable affects on the distribut­ ion of p o p u l a t i o n in West Vancouver. distribution is only approximate. The dating of this anticipated population It is clear, however, that West Vancouver is likely to remain the f a v o u r e d destination for those experiencing upward social mobile. A comparison of Figures 5 and 6 will indicate how radically the retention pattern is expected to shift from Grade 1 to college freshman levels. Eighteen-year-olds make up the f r e s h m a n class in most colleges. J. grade to grade show only termediate levels in North lanation of this pattern lies ·th Vancouver. Generally, irst houses and who intend 3 for several years. This tions in recent and planned There­ fore, in predicting college enrollments, the number of eighteen-year-olds in the population is used as a base for s t a t i s t i c a 1 analysis. The size of the freshman class is expressed as a percentage of this eighteen-year-old group. In the studies prepared for Dr. Macdonald, it was noted that the freshman class would total 42 per cent of eight-year-olds in western Vancouver as compared to 21 per cent of those in western Fraser Valley. Not all eighteen-year-olds will attend college. Some of the freshmen may be bright sixteen-year-olds who have been accelerated through school while others may be adults returning to complete their education. Nevertheless the propensity figures indicated above hold true. they move up through the secondary years. As one rily school district in B. C. seeming paradox indicates ncouver. A home in West has already established an nove into West Vancouver; the schools in the form of .ld be noted that this trend )rth Vancouver also. £ice for the School Board':":' In West Van­ next decade. increases in the number of 1964; West V a n c o u v e r and Part II: The Eastern 1 1963 by the Planning and ver, deals specifically with The eighteen-year-old populations for 1968, 1972, and 1976 jected from students in grades 9, 5, and 1, in 1964-65. have been pro­ Growth rates for North Vancouver are estimated to be 1 per cent per annum (i.e. the five year average), while rates for West Vancouver vary between 3 and 10 per cent depending upon the grade level. There is little reason to expect sharp divergencies in these rates of growth between school districts. There could be changes in the general rates of growth depending upon changing economic conditions. N e a r 1 y 2, 000 eighteen-year-olds will be living on the North Shore in 1968; 2, 400 in 1972; and nearly 3, 000 by 1976. The propensity for hj TABLE 1 clear from the record of of past graduating classei their children. En r o l l m e n t _ C h anges _ _ The majority of stuc programs. The percentc North Vancouver ------· -·----Percent Year Grade Enrollment 1964 9 1,236 1963 8 1962 7 1,227 1,192 1961 6 1, 161 -1.2 1960 5 1,17 5 Percent Grade Enrollment + .7 5 1,508 + l .5 +2.9 4 1,488 +2. 7 3 1,538 -3. 2 + l .6 2 1,513 -2.6 1 1,554 Average Average - secondary school graduat choose the B. C. Institut, other post-secondary ins· directly to work from sec the College qu e s t i o n n; degree. The opening of . school and participate in These records 1 eighteen-year-olds in N c per cent of eighteen-yea account high school drop­ school. Not all of these 1959 1958 1957 195� 4 3 2 1 1,164 centage of eighteen-year. 1,153 1,159 1,158 of the college will be gre would certainly increase Vancouver, in view of the Increase averages less than 1 per cent per annum 1960-64. The Regional Colleg« which has only s l i g h t!: University). About 10 p• dents with i n d e f i n i t e counselling be directed i will attend the College fu West Vancouver Through this analysi 9 539 +2.9 5 551 +6.6 8 524 +5.0 4 517 -0,5 1962 7 3 520 +5.7 6 499 508 -1.8 1961 +2. 8 2 492 +5.3 1 467 1964 1963 1960 5 494 1959 1958 4 3 499 465 1957 2 468 1956 1 424 Increase averages 3 per cent per annum, 1960-64. 1,050 in 1972, and 1,701 year. (See Table 2). ,,, .,, F. T. E. meaning 11F ul" ments into a standard F.T. E, enrollments d -21The propensity for higher education on the North Shore is very high. This is clear from the record of student performance in the secondary schools, the record of past graduating classes, and from the survey of goals parents presently hold for their children. The majority of students in secondary school choose academic or university programs. The percentages are extremely high in West Vancouver. Most of the secondary school graduates either go to University or enroll in Grade 13, 1 Enrollment Percent Average 1,508 +1.5 1,488 1,538 -3. 2 +l . 6 1,513 -2.6 1,554 • A few Training, the School of Art or choose the B. C. Institute of Technology, Nurses other post-secondary institutions. Each year a d e c r e a s i n g percentage is going directly to work from secondary school. Sixty-nine per cent of parents replying to the College q u e s t i o n n a i r e expected that their child would receive a university degree. The opening of a college will e n c o u r a g e students to stay in secondary school and participate in a college program. These r e c o r d s lead us to predict that something over fifty per cent of the eighteen-year-olds in North Vancouver would attend college by 1968 while eighty per cent of eighteen-year-olds in West Vancouver would attend. This takes into account high school drop-outs, and the various terminal programs in the secondary school. Not all of these students will attend a North Shore College, but the per - centage of eighteen-year-olds participating in college programs on the North Shore would certainly increase as the college opportunities become known. The influence of the college will be greatest on those living in the low-propensity areas of North Vancouver, in view of the already close-to-saturation propensities elsewhere. The Regional College will absorb immediately the Grade 13 students (a group which has only s 1 i g h t 1 y declined in 1965 even with the opening of Simon Fraser University). About 10 per cent fewer students will attend University. Many stu­ dents with i n d e f i n i t e goals will attend the Regional College, and through proper counselling be directed into useful and satisfying programs. A number of adults will attend the College full-time either to broaden or to upgrade their education. Through this analysis we predict an F. T. E. ,:, freshman class of 800 in 1968, 551 +6.6 517 -0.5 520 +5.7 492 +5.3 1,050 in 1972, and 1,700 in 1976. year. (See Table 2). Probably 60 per cent would return for second 467 ,:, F. T. E. meaning "Full-Time Equivalent", is a figure condensing partial enroll­ ments into a standard form for calculating space-cost indices. In this report F. T, E, enrollments do not include late afternoon and evening programs. Reliable data on the population are not availabl most other indices of soc Vancouver. To compensa1 was devised. The questic themselves, their commw collected on the particula account of survey techniqt TABLE 2 PROJECTED COLLEGE ENROLLMENT: North Shore Regional College 1968 Freshmen Second Year Total (F. T. E. )':' Late Afternoon and evening':":' _,, ,,. ,:<>:, 1972 - 1,050 600 800 1,650 2,400 4, 100 -- 1976 1,700 1,050 - 2,750 - 8,200 Method of calculating full time student body is discussed in text. Studies of Community Colleges in the United States suggest that in communities like the North Shore the number of persons attending regular classes in late afternoon and evening classes is about t h r e e t i m e s the daytime population. This figure does not include lectures, concerts and other special programs. See publications of Educational Facilities Laboratories Inc. of New York, New York. A North Shore Regional College could open its doors in 1968 with a daytime enrollment of some 800 students, a student body sufficiently large to launch a full comprehensive 2-year college p rogram. 4. Distinctiveness of the North Shore Population The residents of North and West Vancouver have some of the highest average levels of education and income to be found anywhere in Canada. More managers and professional p e o p l e. make their homes on the North Shore than in any other section of the metropolitan Vancouver region, with the sole exception of the south Shaughnessy area of Vancouver. Although variations in occupations are not easily gleaned from the Census (which does not identify District Municipalities as incor­ porated urban places), there is no doubt that the municipalities of the North Shore contribute many of the pacesetters of our society. The potential benefits to our economy and society will be impressive if the young people of these communities are given full and adequate education. 'f' Although there are tE North Shore, the concent1 this variation is critical i maps have been prepare< socio-economic status. J families of children in Gr 1972, and was selected £o between elementary and s Occupations. (See Fi father is a manager - a s times the metropolitan av in the residential district! is not to suggest that man more are localized in the: 0 n e - f i f t' h of the fa engineers, architects, te; third in the central and w, sections of North Vancou, In the Delbrook and occupations is_ encounter, found in approximately eq In the 1 o w e r levels sections of the City of N craft and trade occupatior The number of fathe1 very much higher on the For the e n t i r e u r b a n managerial occupations a1 ,:, While it would perhap sociologists I index sea nor the questionnaire p -23Reliable data on the social and economic characteristics of the North Shore population are not available. While income statistics are published in the Census, most other indices of social class are not recroded, except for the City of North r: Vancouver. To compensate for this lack of data, the regional college questionnaire was devised. The questionnaire was d e s i g n e d to find out how people perceived themselves, their community, and their mobility within it; specifically, data were collected on the particular family and child. A copy of the questionnaire and an account of survey techniques are included in the Appendix. 2 1976 1,700 1,050 2,750 10 8, 200 Although there are tendencies towards high social status>:< m all areas of the North Shore, the concentration varies from place to place. The identification of • this variation is critical in planning the 1 o c a t i o n of the regional college. maps have been prepared, illustrating in general terms the regional variation in socio-economic status. It will be noted that the maps summarize data about the families of children in Grade 5 only. This group is the potential freshman class of 1972, and was selected for presentation because it r e p r e s e n t s a medial picture between elementary and secondary school levels. Occupations. (See Figure 1) Half of the responding families indicate that the father is a manager - a startlingly high figure considering that it is roughly four times the metropolitan average. ;ed in text. .ggest that in communities g regular classes in late Four Furthermore, managers tend to be concentrated in the residential districts adjacent to the Capilano River and in Lynn Valley. This is not to suggest that managers are not numerous elsewhere, r a t h e r that many more are localized in these particular areas. 0 n e - f i fth of the fathers are c 1 a s s e d as professional: s the daytime population. doctors, lawyers, other special programs. engineers, architects, teachers, clergymen and the like. s Inc. of New York, New third in the central and western s e c t i o n s of West Vancouver and in the eastern The figure rises to one sections of North Vancouver. In the Delbrook and upper Lonsdale areas of North Vancouver, a mixture of Sales personnel, managers, and professionals are s in 1968 with a daytime occupations is_ encountered. 1tly large to launch a full found in approximately equal percentage, with sales slightly predominent. In the 1 o w e r levels of North Vancouver, the Norgate area, and in the older sections of the City of North Vancouver, sharp rises are noted in the number of craft and trade occupations. ne of the highest average Canada. More managers th Shore than in any other ole exception of the south >ccupations are not easily The number of fathers reporting managerial and professional occupations is very much higher on the North Shore than in metropolitan Vancouver as a whole. For the e n t i r e u r b a n region, in 1961, 13. 4 per cent of the labour force was in managerial occupations and 9. 4 per cent were classed as professionals. t Municipalities as incor­ alities of the North Shore � potential benefits to our >ple of these communities ,:, While it would perhaps have been instructive to measure class on one of the sociologists' index scales (Blishen, for example), neither the Census material nor the questionnaire provided sufficiently complete data. Income. (Figure 2) Hill-British Properties the respondents to our $12, 000. The central an, ly high incomes, as did t aging in the $8,000 - $10, . Drive, the majority of tr. of our questionnaire. Tl North Vancouver have in The concentration oJ West Vancouver and the Father's education. questionnaire indicated t al 18 per cent had compl · OCCUPATIONS - of fathers of Grade 5 children. Shadings represent significant On the other hand, rougl degrees. This is much J deviations from the North Shore average - predominantly managerial Elllllll[llli professional and mixed occupations � [ sales and professional Vancouver as a whole. crafts, trades, and mixed occupations The areal variation observed on the other m, North Shore average: managerial 58%; professional 19%; crafts and trades 11%; sales 8%; others 4% Fi�e I British Properties area� West Vancouver, the pr, sections of Lynn Valley, graduation plus some sp cases, less than the ave trast, the r e g i o n s arc Schools are areas where not completed high schc degree reside there. Educational Goals. expectations for their cl: •' theless we feel it highly argument; social class i tontalls r'9MOt"Ch limited ' of their children. On tl Grade 5 alone) of their c at least one university d are well above the metre as a whole.,:, Again, the ations are highly carrel, FAMILY INCOME- among parents of Grade 5 children high low E --_ ::1 average F'if1,¥t 2 In summary, we ha1 ltt®tltmimt®il very high North Shore average, $9,460 ,:, At present less than 2 British Columbia. -25Income. (Figure 2) The highest family incomes are reported for the Sentinel Hill-British Properties neighbourhoods of West Vancouver, where 75 per cent of the respondents to our questionnaire i n d i c a t e d a household income exceeding $12,000. The central and western sections of West Vancouver indicated moderate­ ly high incomes, as did the families in Delbrook, Capilano and Lynn Valley, aver­ aging in the $8,000 - $10,000 range. In contrast, in the Norgate area below Marine Drive, the majority of the households indicated incomes in the lowest two divisions of our questionnaire. The majority of the families in the older areas of the City of North Vancouver have incomes between $4,000 and $6,000. The concentration of high income groups as well as responsible occupations in I- West Vancouver and the upper levels of North Vancouver is triking. Father's education. (Figure 3) Thirty per cent of the fathers responding to the questionnaire indicated that they had less than high school graduation. An addition­ al 18 per cent had completed high school and had had no further formal education. represent significant On the other hand, roughly 47 per cent indicated that they have partial university degrees. This is much higher than the average for the male population in greater Vancouver as a whole. issional md mixed occupations The areal variation in father's education follows similar p a t ter n s to·those observed on the other maps. V.,; sales 8%; others 4% Nearly 75 per cent of the fathers in the Sentinel Hill­ British Properties areas hold one or more university degrees. In other sections of West Vancouver, the proportion who are university trained is relatively high. In sections of Lynn Valley, Delbrook and Capilano, most fathers indicate high school graduation plus some specialized training or partial university. In each of these cases, less than the average number indicate a full university education. trast, the r e g i o n s around the Norgate, Queen Mary In con­ and Westview Elementary Schools are areas wherein approximately forty to fifty per cent of the fathers have not completed high school. Very f e w , if indeed any, fathers with a university degree reside there. Educational Goals. (Figure 4) While some might cavil at including parental expectations for their children's education as an indicator of social class, never­ l theless we feel it highly germane here. This is really the primum mobile of the argument; social class is its explanation. North Shore parents expect a great deal of their children. On the a v e r a g e , they expect that 69 per cent (71 per cent in Grade 5 alone) of their off spring will not complete their formal education short of at least one university degree. While these are likely ambitious expectations, they are well above the metropolitan average and far above the average for the Province as a whole.,:, Again, the areal variation within the region is significant. Expect­ ations are highly correlated with the three variables treated above. 5 children In summary, we have used four indices of socio-economic status to indicate ,:, At present less than 20 per cent of the 18-21 year population attend University in British Columbia. •' () ' FATHER'S EDUCATION: ! l Most fathers have less than Grade 12 ( __ -j Most ff British Columbia and iploma. The student is L a particular academic f a i r 1 y broad range of College will be to pro­ and Science at the Uni­ .port, however, it is not ;e at the universities. In iversity of Victoria and ssible to match courses t individual courses will will vary with the nature s general agreement on sequence of what should be taught - such as chemistry, physics, mathematics - it is likely that the college courses will be quite close to those at the universities. In subjects which are not so organized, however - English, history, sociology, for example - it is better that the college should choose staff with good q u a 1 if i c a t i o n s and allow them to develop the courses they think best for themselves. They, like all the department heads, would be well advised to discuss with the various universities the courses they propose, but they should be prepared to make their own decisions in the belief that they will do best that which they are most enthusiastic about. It should be recognized that it would be unwise and uneconomic for a two-year college to try to provide courses comparable with all of those given at the univer­ sities. Provided the college gives the b a s i c c o u r s e s , students will be able to transfer to university in the main areas of study. With those reservations, it is likely that the college would want to offer first and second year university c o u r s e s in economics, English, geography, history, psychology, sociology, modern languages, mathematics, biology, chemistry and physics. In the beginning it is probable that one or two modern languages would be sufficient. Programs p�culiar to the Regional College. It is very much more difficult to advise on that part of the curriculum distinctive to the Regional College than on the purely academic. There is a strong tradition of what constitutes the basic subjects in academic programs; not so in other fields. These others, it should be noted, are n o t n e c e s s a ri 1 y t e c h n i c a 1. Some authorities refer to them as "sub­ professional", in that graduates perform somewhat less complicated tasks in busi­ ness and government than the professionals, who are p r e s u m a b 1 y graduates of university academic and professional schools. Normally, a student enrolled on "college II programs would take some core academic subjects, probably in language, mathematics, and social science, plus special courses in fields where employment will be sought, such as business management, accounting, marketing, advertising, and computer methods. Courses in communications, such as journalism, radio and television, photography and graphic arts will also be appropriate. Further­ more, while the demand for m o r e h i g h 1 y specialized technical training may be largely satisfied by the B. C. Institute of Technology, it seems likely to us that the college administration might work with 1 o c a 1 public and business institutions to develop joint training courses. The college should provide a wide range of courses designed for the partial student. These will develop from the basic departments, but will almost certainly need to be supplemented by courses relating to the fine arts, music, theatre and recreation. The increased leisure of today has created considerable demand for such courses. Many of them can be taught in the evening by part-time instructors. and many of them need not be repeated every semester. These programs do not significantly increase capital costs, since they represent only greater utilization of buildings needed for daytime use. If the college faculty is alert, it will sense the needs of the community and provide a centre for adult education and recreation. -30- The salvage function. The college should incorporate into its program the adult secondary school programs currently offered by the school districts. This invaluable service allows individu'als, who dropped out of school, an opportunity of completing their secondary school education in a mature adult environment. I I In conclusion it cannot be emphasized too often that one of the major functions of the college is to provide comprehensive programs of mixed academic and non­ academic nature. It is easy to staff and o r g a n i z e academic programs because there is relatively little room for radical departures from the programs of existing universities. Given the ease of s e t t i n g t h e m u p , and frequently their relative cheapness compared with technical programs, it is easy to imagine that a college administration might be seduced into concentrating all its i n i t i a 1 efforts on the academic programs. It would be disastrous if this occurred however. The great opportunity for the college to serve the community will be seized most avidly by those who have the imagination to develop the technical and sub-professional pro­ grams so badly needed. 2. The Academic Calendar Any regional college will be faced with a decision as to what calendar it should operate on. The choice of calendar is very i m p o r t a n t and is closely related to curriculum. One of the great advantages of the regional college is that it allows students to discover their interests and abilities, and switch where necessary to subjects for which they are better suited. This is best accomplished by having the year divided into several parts. In Canada most universities operate on an aca­ demic year, from September to May. Simon Fraser University has adopted a tri­ mester system in which the year is divided into three terms of sixteen weeks. Two semesters of sixteen weeks equal the traditional academic year. Many American colleges use a q u a r t e r s y s t e m , wherein three quarters are normally taken to represent the traditional Canadian academic year, although in fact, the stud�nts spend nearly a month longer at their studies. Arguments about the virtues of the v a r i o u s systems abound. The quarter system has a slightly longer year and may be particularly suitable for students who are undecided about their academic goals, just as the slightly longer year of the traditional Grade 13 in British Columbia has given students an o p p o r t u n i t y they may miss at university to settle better into their studies. The great flexibility of the quarter system arises from the fact that students can g r a d u a 11 y "find them­ selves" academically. They may begin by believing that they are bound for univer­ sity and thus take a traditional academic program. As they discover that either their interests or their talents do not justify their continuing such a program they may switch easily into a combination of academic and sub-professional courses. On the other hand, there would be advantages in a trimester system. It fits the traditional academic year and the trimester system at Simon Fraser and Van­ couver City College s o m e w h a t better than the quarter system; moreover, many people believe that the four-month semester is a better unit pedagogically than the three-month quarter. We would not reco We would leave such a c ever, strongly advise a must register in Septen year at the very least, the cost of boredom or flexibility of shorter un students; there is no re a subject should not be of material but lasting community college is t, sional interests. He Cc 3. College faculty The Academic Boa academic faculty for r recent training in gradl for faculty with technic Judging from the e. College, there should 1: College. The e s t a b 1 metropolis within a fev. individuals. The LowE environmental amenitiE and aesthetic sensibilit The selection of fa will be crucial to the s, the college, must reprc ity. In a new kind of i are responsible for ma ,:� "Memorandum to Bo of School District 01 Minister of Educatio te into its program the school districts. This chool, an opportunity of lult environment. e of the major functions ixed academic and nonemic programs because the programs of existing frequently their relative ) imagine that a college i n i t i a 1 efforts on the ·ed however. The great e seized most avidly by d sub-professional pro- three-month quarter. We would not recommend firmly either the quarter or the trimester system. We would leave such a decision to the Regional College Council. We would, how­ ever, strongly advise against the traditional University academic year. If students must register in September and pursue the courses they have then chosen for a full year at the very least, many of them will drop out; others will succeed, but only at the cost of boredom or anxiety. It is most important that students now be given the flexibility of shorter units of time. It is not a matter of making courses easier for students; there is no reason whatsoever why two or three courses in succession in a subject should not be at least as difficult as a course covering the same amount of material but lasting for one year. It is rather that one of the key functions of a community college is to enable the student to discover his academic and professional interests. He can do this best if he can switch rapidly in his early years. 3. ) what calendar it should and is closely related to college is that it allows itch where necessary to omplished by having the ities operate on an aca­ ,rsity has adopted a tri­ .s of sixteen weeks. Two : year. Many American rs are normally taken to �h in fact, the students 1s abound. The quarter ;;uitable for students who ghtly longer year of the s an o p p o r t u n i t y they The great flexibility of gr a d u a l l y "find them­ .ey are bound for univer­ hey discover that either Lng such a program they professional courses. ·imester system. It fits Simon Fraser and Van­ :ystem; moreover, many it pedagogically than the -31- College faculty The Academic Board has published statements r e g a r d i n g qualifications of academic faculty for regional colleges.,:, The Board stresses the impor tance of recent training in graduate schools for academic posts. No clear guidance is given for faculty with technical competence, but similar principles surely apply. Judging from the experience of Simon Fraser University and Vancouver City College, there should be l i t t l e d i f f i c u l t y recruiting faculty for a North Shore College. The e s t a b 1 i s h m e n t of a college in a high-income suburb of a major metropolis within a few miles of a major university should appeal to many qualified individuals. The Lower Mainland, in an area p a r t i c u 1 a r 1 y well endowed with environmental amenities, has never had difficulty attracting people of intellectual and aesthetic sensibilities. The selection of faculty, particularly of Principal and departmental Chairmen, will be crucial to the success of the college. These individuals, the pacesetters of the college, must represent and interpret the essence of the North Shore commun­ ity. In a new kind of institution, they are the innovators. Ultimately, they alone are responsible for making the college an exciting place to study and work. ,,, ,,, "Memorandum to Boards of School Trustees who are considering Establishment of School District or Regional Colleges", August 1964 (s i g n e d L. R. Peterson, Minister of Education), p. 2. p 11 0 � -.. l> -... �. tlo ... = ::I :::0 ID Q. 0 C m ID "C ID en 1. ""C ID C ::I There are a numbei satisfy in order to be a ""C en r- < CJ) ID "C C (a) cc en !'! U1 en cc Q. In the long-run, mi riding importance. terms of real cost� government by 1 o VI 0 0 General Considerat from the center of : it c:, travel effort. I co �"!' (b) In the short-run, le and recognition. f T offer ease of visua stand out as a clea en and even partisan c :;· ID ID ID ID co ....-... ... ;•.. ... . . ..... ..· .·...· ·:..-::· : ·.·.: .. . .... . . .. . :.... ..:.. .·.. .. ... .. . . . . · . . .· . ·.· . .. :._· .. .: .:. ·.. ::·...·. . : .. .· .. ... . . . .·.·:.. :. =:: : :·. (c) Certain scale effec scales (that is, the critical argument. sites must be analy arterial routes of t exit routes to avoic (d) A minimum of twen approximately 2-4 adjunct to any con fields and so forth. buildings onto a m costs - it must be 1 location, is part oJ seventy acres woul Since the ultimate - shore and steep slc for the North Shor Q :ii, ""I size, Simon Frase College plans to me :a: c,, :a: ... .... ....... ... Q :ii, C, Q C, c,, ""I c::: Q ""C ,:, Questions o f physica: publications of Especially useful he Colleges, Rice UnivE IV. 1. COLLEGE LOCATION General Considerations There are a number of c o n d i t i o n s which a community college location must satisfy in order to be a success. (a) In the long-run, minimum aggregate t r a v e 1 for the "customers" is of over­ riding importance. This results in the minimum possible social cost, both in terms of real costs to individuals and m a x i m u m s a v i n g s to all levels of government by 1 o w e r i n g access costs. The college must be located not far from the center of its student hinterland, m e a s u r e d in terms of aggregate travel effort. (b) In the short-run, location will determine the degree of community acceptance and recognition. To be successful, the site must satisfy (a), but it must also offer ease of visual identification. It must be distinctively located: it must stand out as a clearly recognized focus of North Shore educational, cultural, and even partisan community life. (c) Certain scale effects on location must be taken into account. At small map­ scales (that is, the s i t u a t i o n a l level of generality), (a) above is again the critical argument. At large map-scales (site), questions of particular road sites must be analysed. The site chosen should have easy access to the major arterial routes of the region, and it should have at least two major entrance exit routes to avoid peak-time congestion, (d) A minimum of twenty acres of land is necessary. This would break down to approximately 2-4 acres for buildings, 5-10 acres for parking (a necessary adjunct to any co m m u t e r college), and 7-10 acres for landscaping, playing fields and so forth. While a competent architect could squeeze the necessary buildings onto a m i n i m a 11 y - s i z e d site - at the price of increased building costs - it must be remembered that a college once established in a particular location, is part of the long term cultural landscape of the region. Forty to seventy acres would be desirable to allow for flexibility in future expansions. Since the ultimate growth of population on the North Shore is limited by sea­ shore and steep slopes, we see an ultimate enrollment of some 3, 000 students for the North Shore Regional College. For a student body presently of this size, Simon Fraser University has allowed about 60 acres. Vancouver City College plans to move onto a 25 acre site on the Langara Golf Course.,:, ,:, Questions o f physical planning are particularly well d i s c u s s e d in the various p u b l i c a t i o n s o f Educational Facilities Laboratories, Inc., of New York. Especially useful here is the E. F. L. - financed study, 10 Designs/ Community Colleges, Rice University, 1962. -34The above conditions may be considered mandatory. Three further considerations which could help immensely, but are not to be taken as necessary, are the follow­ ing: (e) (£) Sociologically speaking, it is difficult enough to encourage people to partici­ pate in novel activities in a well-known and familiar place. The difficulties are compounded if these activities are to take place at an eccentric location reached by unfamiliar routes. If the college site is adjacent or close to certain other functional areas in the urban fabric, substantial savings and indeed wholly new benefits can result. (i) Some service facilities, s u c h as eating places, bookstores, stationers, and apparel stores, will be needed on campus or nearby. If the college were built beside an already existing commercial area, the capital cost of the institution could be lowered and the nearby merchants benefitted. (ii) Possibilities exist for some forms of multiple land use. If the site chosen were adjacent to an existing park, for instance, students might use some park areas for extra-curricular activities, while park-users would benefit by the addition of a park-like campus to their usual recreation areas. (g) It is always preferable that a site be in only one political jurisdiction. (h) Reasonably level land is always cheaper to build upon. Wide tolerances are permissible, but extremely p r e c i p i t o u s sites, such as those that straddle North Shore creekbeds will incur ruinous building costs. (i) Location within the nexus of urban affairs would be somewhat of an innovation locally. Both existing Universities suffer from what might be termed "Ivory Tower II locations, one on a peninsula and the other on a mountaintop. Such an urban location should be instrumental in making the college an attractive place for the whole family at one time or another. From the statistical evidence presented in the previous section and summariz­ ed in Figure 6, it is very clear that West Vancouver will provide more students per capita for a college program than North Vancouver. Also the participation in any North Shore college by young people from the Howe Sound and Sechelt School Districts would add to the number of people coming to the college from the west. As was suggested in the population analysis, the filling in of the eastern side of North Vancouver, i.e. t h e a r e a b e t w e e n Seymour Creek and Deep Cove, will probably be s 1 o w , accelerating some time in the late 1970 's (see Figure 5). So much for the static distribution of people; equally important are the existing pat­ terns of interaction. From the analysis of intra-urban travel patterns of North Shore residents, it is clear that two major destinations exist for community services other than down­ town Vancouver. These of course are Park Royal and Lonsdale between Thirteenth en UJ t- en UJ C) UJ ..J ..J 0 u -> .. UJ �� z: a:: .. UJ � ..... ,! !:i] <: Dre �ur u DDDDr ._____________ l DODD[ iDDD[ : further considerations essary, are the follow- Cl) LLI - I- lrage people to partici­ place. The difficulties tt an eccentric location functional areas in the v benefits can result. Cl) LLI C) LLI ..J ..J 0 u > -· bookstores, stationers, nearby. If the college trea, the capital cost of LLI �chants benefitted. z: .. a:: LLI � . use. If the site chosen :udents might use some :1.rk-users would benefit L recreation areas. t:: i �..!! �] <(: :1.l jurisdiction. Wide tolerances are 1 as those that straddle s. newhat of an innovation night be termed "Ivory t mountaintop. Such an lege an attractive place section and summariz­ provide more students :... und and Sechelt School .... college from the west. q, Lso the participation in of the eastern side of iek and Deep Cove, will 70 's ( see Figure 5). So tt are the existing pat- •rth Shore residents, it rvices other than down­ iale between Thirteenth ...... ........ ... • C,:» c:::,-: c.,� :::: QI: ... c:::,:: :a:: : .. C,:» : .... :a:: • � QI: !: . c:::, ________________________ .. ___., :ii:! -36and Seventeenth. We know from other studies carried out in conjunction with the U. B. C. Urban Core Project that the residents of peripheral sections of the North Shore, in westernmost West Vancouver and eastwards towards Deep Cove, will by­ pass intervening shopping centers such as Ambleside to make the majority of their purchases in one of the two main sho p p i n g d i s t r i c t s . The evidence from our questionnaire substantiates these travel patterns. Taking into account the actual and potential distribution of college students, and the established patterns of interaction on the North Shore, we recommend that the site chosen for the North Shore Regional College should be somewhere between Lonsdale in North Vancouver and Taylor Way in West Vancouver. A location in this area would be a major step towards fulfilling the college's role as a commun­ ity focus. The land position within these boundaries is very tight. Six possible sites are identified and discussed below. The final choice of site will, of course, be made by the Regional College Council. Each of the six parcels suggested in this report is to some degree o w n e d by one or another level of g o v e r n m e n t or could be assembled with the assistance of one of the higher levels of government. We have endeavoured to indicate advantages and disadvantages of each site and give some evaluation of them for consideration of the Regional College Council. 2. Six Sites (a) The Park Royal Site (Figure 7, reference A) An attractive site on the western boundary of the acceptable area lies immedi­ ately to the south of Eaton 1 s section of Park Royal. A tract of provincially-owned land, designated District Lot 5521A, is bounded by Park Royal, the Capilano River, the First Narrows, and Ambleside Park. It is bisected by the right-of-way of the Pacific Great Eastern Railway. The southern part of the property, from the tracks to the water is presently under short-term lease to the District of West Vancouver for an extension to Ambleside Park. The site has a number of very r e a l a d v a n t a g e s . It is provincially owned, undeveloped, and larger than the minimum size required for a college site. It is adjacent to one of the two major commercial and recreational concentrations on the North Shore, with a consequently great potential for complementarity of function and multiple land use. It is adjacent to established playing fields. The property itself has a magnificent view of Stanley Park and Burrard Inlet. A college there would be clearly identified by people crossing the Lions Gate Bridge. The site has potential access from Marine Drive near Ambleside Park, and from the Upper Levels Highway, through an extension of Taylor Way skirting the Capilano south of Park Royal. Traffic could also be dranw from the Upper Levels from the n e w c 1 o v e r 1 e a f planned for the area just east of Taylor Way. If the college is to become the location of a North Shore community theatre and cultural center and if it is used e::i evening parking could prob The major disadvanta confine the built-up part a way and Eaton's store. Tl not be too great, h o w e v e commuter train services v Traffic coming along Keith through the congested Capi relatively expensive secon constructed.,:, There is n1 As far as creating a s· .est opportunities of any si1 (b) The Capilano Bridge S An interesting site for ated at the northern end of end of the bridge, the Capi: parcel of land has been de Vancouver. The size of th At present, the property i1 the site would have to be < istered by the District of T' mean that students going tc arterials would have to pr an awkward business at be ceivably be by foot over th The major d i s a d v a r awkwardly shaped. Accesi related to plans for a seco: ing shows an e x t e n s i o 1 Third Street to the Upper (c) The Capilano View Sit A third site in the san View Cemetery, the Distr and the Upper Levels High West Vancouver Parks Be Properties. Part has beer ,:, Such a crossing has app Planning Department foi t in conjunction with the al sections of the North Lrds Deep Cove, will by­ Lke the majority of their The evidence from our ion of college students, re, we recommend that l be somewhere between ncouver. A location in ge's role as a commun - Six possible sites are ill, of course, be made suggested in this report re r n m e n t or could be f government. We have each site and give some e Council. )table area lies immedi­ ct of provincially-owned )yal, the Capilano River, · the right-of-way of the roperty, from the tracks ,trict of West Vancouver It is provincially owned, :or a college site. It is :i.al concentrations on the Lplementarity of function :i.g fields. The property d Inlet. A college there .te Bridge. 1.r Ambleside Park, and Taylor Way skirting the ' from the Upper Levels t of Taylor Way. If the 1ity theatre and cultural -37center and if it is used extensively for nighttime adult education, supplementary evening parking could probably be made available within the Park Royal complex. The major disadvantage to the site is the P. G. E. right-of-way, which might confine the built-up part of the campus to the smaller area between the right-of­ way and Eaton's store. The nuisance value of the infrequent P. G. E. trains should not be too great, h o w e v e r , and could conceivably be a significant advantage, if commuter train services were introduced - a point that applies equally to (d) below. Traffic coming along Keith and Marine from North Vancouver would have to travel through the congested Capilano-Marine and Taylor-Marine intersections, unless a relatively expensive second crossing of the Capilano south of Marine Drive were constructed.,:, There is no indication of how much the land might be worth. As far as creating a symbol of North Shore personality, it proffers the great­ .est opportunities of any site for a creative planner and architect. (b) The Capilano Bridge Site (Figure 7, reference B) An interesting site for a college could be District Lot 790, the property situ­ ated at the northern end of the Lions Gate Bridge, bounded by the cloverleaf at the end of the bridge, the Capilano River, and the municipal boundary to the east. This parcel of land has been designated for parks purposes by the Municipality of West Vancouver. The size of the site is in the lower range of possibilities for a college. At present, the property is inaccessible from any major road system. Access to the site would have to be developed from Capilano Road through property admin­ istered by the District of North Vancouver. A c c e s s f r o m Capilano Road would mean that students going to the c o 11 e g e site by either of the two main east-west arterials would have to proceed onto busy Capilano Road and thence into the site; an awkward business at best. Access to the s e r v i c e s of Park Royal could con­ ceivably be by foot over the present Capilano Bridge on Marine Drive. I The major d i s a d v a n t a g e s are several. The site is relatively small and awkwardly shaped. Access is poor. The site has an uncertain future, particularly related to plans for a second crossing of the Narrows. One plan for the new cross­ ing shows an e x t e n s i o n of the bridge through the property and then 11;orth along Third Street to the Upper Levels Highway. (c) The Capilano View Site (Figure 7, reference C) A third site in the same vicinity is a group of properties between the Capilano View Cemetery, the District of North Vancouver boundary adjacent to the river, and the Upper Levels Highway. Part of this property is being d e v e 1 o p e d by the West Vancouver Parks Board as a p 1 a y i n g f i e 1 d for the residents of British Properties. Part has been used as a dump by the Municipality. ,:, Such a crossing has apparently been under d i s c u s s i o n by the West Vancouver Planning Department for some time. -38Its future is rather uncertain, again because plans for the interchanges on the Upper Levels Highway linking a new First Narrows crossing may involve part of this property. Its chief advantage would seem to be that in many ways, it symbo­ lizes the essence of the North Shore, being well-treed and bordered on the east by a precipitous drop into the Capilano River. Presumably any plans for interchanges could make provision for proper entrances into this site. (d) The Capilano Indian ReserveSite (Figure 7, reference D) The o n 1 y p a r c e 1 of land within the areal bounds recommended in this study which approaches the upper limit of land n e c e s s a r y for a college site is on the Capilano Indian Reserve Number 5, immediately e a s t of the Lions Gate Bridge. The land is presently controlled by the Indian band in that area and any agreement on the leasing of land for college purposes would have to be made with the Indian band and their advisors. Land of this quality, adjacent to deep-sea docking facil­ ities and a commercial core sufficiently large to accommodate shopping needs for some time in the future, an� without any other major use in sight, should not com­ mand too high a price. The great strength of the site is the availability of a large area of level land. It is at present underused. In the event of a second span being built parallel to the present Lions Gate Bridge, a small p o r t i o n of the Reserve would be taken up by the bridge itself. However, the quantity of land available is such that, even then, an adequate college site could be developed. If a section of the Capilano Indian Reserve Number 5 were chosen as a site, some access changes would have to be made. Welch Street, coming in from the east, would have to be improved and in all probability would have to be extended along the northern boundary of D. L. 5521 t o c o n n e c t with Marine Drive and A m b 1 e s i d e . This would give access to the college site from the heavily popu­ lated sections of West Vancouver and the City of North Vancouver with the major advantage of not involving traffic with the present congested access to the Lions Gate Bridge. This of course would necessitate bridging the Capilano River, but as noted above, such a bridge has been considered for some time to relieve congest­ ion around the terminus of the Lions Gate Bridge anyway. A second advantage of a bridge across the Capilano is that the college site could be linked to the services presently existing in Park Royal and could be integrated into a North Shore com­ munity focus. An entrance to the property could easily be developed from Capilano Road and Marine Drive. The site also offers the same sort of p o s i t i v e visual ident ification from the Lions Gate Bridge as the Park Royal site discussed above. At the present time the pipelines connecting the Cleveland Dam with the Van­ couver water supply network run below this property. Care would have to be taken to ensure that college plans would not conflict with the vital pipeline right-of-way. The disadvantages of this site would seem to be related to the uncertainty of the tenure position for the Indian-controlled land and the proximity of the site t o t h e P. G. E. railway right-of-way and the expansion of the Vancouver Wharves develop­ ment onto the Indian Reserve shoreline. A parcel of land ·in this area to the east of the Lions Gate Bridge, part of Block 6 of D. L. 5521, is owned by the Provincial Government, hovvever, and it might be possible to obtain freehold land tenure on the Provincially-owned le facilities, playing fields, (e) The North Vancouve1 Recently, a policy of City Council concerning t: from St. Patrick I s to thE old retail core of lower J an eight or nine block art The area to the west of L could conceivably be an could probably be ksseml Housing Act. As the Act presumably could not affc Government, through the could have real advantagE and probably of upgradin� The disadvantages of areas of North and Wes· Highway would have to be t r a f f i c , or from the ea Marine Drive, also well­ Esplanade to First and tr. Capilano, this could give small side, and its deep-sea docking facil­ odate shopping needs for in sight, should not com­ he availability of a large nt of a second span being ::>o r t i o n of the Reserve ntity of land available is v-eloped. i were chosen as a site, :eet, coming in from the ould have to be extended with Marine Drive and e from the heavily popu­ ·ancouver with the major isted access to the Lions he Capilano River, but as time to relieve congestA second advantage of be linked to the services into a North Shore com­ developed from Capilano sort of p o s i t i v e visual ,al site discussed above. v-eland Dam with the Van­ re would have to be taken ;al pipeline right-of-way. to the uncertainty of the :imity of the site t o t h e tcouver Wharves develop­ d ·in this area to the east 3 owned by the Provincial L freehold land tenure on -39- the Provincially-owned land and 1 e a-s e 1 a n d from the Indian Reserve for parking facilities, playing fields, and other land-extensive college uses. (e) The North Vancouver Redevelopment Area (Figure 7, reference E) Recently, a policy of redevelopment has been suggested to the North Vancouver City Council concerning the land between Third Street and Esplanade and stretching from St. Patrick's to the Indian Reserve. This redevelopment area includes the old retail core of lower Lonsdale, a residential area to the east of Lonsdale, and an eight or nine block area to the west with mixed land ownership and mixed uses. The area to the west of Lonsdale, t e r m i n a t i n g at the Indian Reserve Number 1, could conceivably be an urban site for a North Shore Regional College. The land could probably be kssembled and purchased through the provisions of the National Housing Act. As the Act reads, if the land were to be put to c o 11 e g e use, a use presumably could not afford the c u r r e n t m a r k e t price of the land, the Federal Government, through the N.H.A., would subsidize the assembly of the land. This could have real advantages in revitalizing the commercial core of lower Lonsdale and probably of upgrading real estate in adjacent areas. The disadvantages of this site are those of inaccessibility to the p e r i p h e r a 1 areas of North and West Vancouver and beyond. Access from the Upper Levels Highway would have to be via Lonsdale, a street which already has relatively heavy t r a f f i c , or from the east via Keith Road or Third Avenue and from the west by Marine Drive, also well-travelled routes. If a new w a t e r f r o n t road connected Esplanade to First and then to Welch and a n e w b r i d g e w e r e built across the Capilano, this could give access from a waterfront route. Again, the site is on the small side, and its development would have to be in terms of an urban type of site which would not characterize the North Shore. It is possible that the City of North Vancouver will have made other plans for the use of reassembled and redeveloped land. (f) Indian Residential School Site (Figure 7, reference F) A sixth site for consideration could be the land including and surrounding the Indian Residential School in the City of North Vancouver. It has been suggested that the Federal Government is considering a revision of its policy on Indian education, and it may prove necessary for the Government to abandon the site. The portion of Indian Reserve Number 1 north of Third is m u c h 1 e s s heavily occupied than the areas to the south, and nearby blocks of residential land are also underused. This parcel of land, obviously on the lower end of our size scale, could be assembled as a redevelopment project. Both the North Vancouver R e d e v e 1 o p m e n t a r e a and this· site would have relatively severe problems of access from the Upper Levels Highway. However, if the second crossing of the First Narrows is t e r m i n a t e d on the North Shore near Pemberton Avenue (a development that appears daily less likely), and a connection to the Upper Levels were constructed up the Mackay Creek ravine, then presumably interchanges would be constructed at Marine Drive and Pemberton, a short distance -40from t h e two Both sites are on the eastern edge of the area chances of the college be Several sites have been recommended to us which All in all, it is fortu North Shore, three sites s i t e s in question. designated as desirable. A note on eccentric sites. are outside the area discussed above. In particular, two sites have been selected by the Municipal Planner for the District of North Vancouver. Bo t h common meeting ground. the home of the North She a r e in the Inter-river area between Lynn and Seymour Creeks. In both cases, most of the land is owned by the Municipality, and the parcels are in the upper range of site sizes recommended in this report. We would not recommend that these sites be given high p r i o r i t y . isolated from the e s t a b 1 i s h e d They are 2000 f o c i of North Shore community activity and are remote from the bulk of students who have high propensities for higher education. We believe that the college must be i n t e g r a t e d i n t o the community and would caution the Regional College Council about considering exotic and pastoral sites for what is properly an important central function of the urban area. We would reject these eastern sites for a second reason: West Vancouver people do not often pene­ trate far into North Vancouver, either for social or commercial purposes. If the college is to develop as a community focus, it must be located 1500 at least on neutral ground. 1000 Recommendations. After considering very carefully the six sites within the area between Lonsdale and Taylor Way and noting eccentric location proposals, we believe that only three of the sites should be given consideration by the Regional College Council. These are the Park Royal site, the Capilano Indian Reserve Number 5 property, and the proposed North Vancouver City redevelopment area, designated A, D, and E on the 500 accompanying map. The other sites are rejected because of the u n c e r t a i n t y of bridge and road building sites near the Capilano, and the third because there is no firm policy a n n o u n c e d by the Federal Government regarding Indian residential schools. Some basic d e c i s i o n s will have to be made by the Regional College Council before the final site selection is made. Statements of the role that the college is to play in the day-to-day life of the community must be assessed. have to be c 1 e a r 1 y identified. N.Von 19 Its functions will If the college is to be the center of academic and cultural life on the North Shore, a site must be s e 1 e c t e d which will enhance the college's chance to fulfill these objectives. Any of these three sites, on balance, could provide these qualities. In terms of maximum accessibility, the sites adjacent to the bridgehead would have consider­ able advantages not only for residents of the North Shore but also those from Howe Sound and Sechelt. Whatever the location chosen for a new First Narrows cross­ ing, the fact remains that all routes converge on this bridgehead center. Eccentric locations would add to aggregate travel costs and would severely jeopardize the Figure 6 STUC eastern edge of the area commended to us which ;ites have been selected .ver. Bo t h a r e in the both cases, most of the the upper range of site b. p r i o r i t y . They are nmunity activity and are es for higher education. b.e community and would tic and pastoral sites for area. We would reject people do not often pene1ercial purposes. If the cated at least on neutral -41chances of the college being readily recognized by all North Shore residents as a common meeting ground, All in all, it is fortunate that after twenty years of rapid urban growth on the North Shore, three sites can still be recommended for detailed consideration as the home of the North Shore Regional College. 2000 1500 1000 le area between Lonsdale re believe that only three College Council. These nber 5 property, and the nated A, D, and E on the of the u n c e r t a i n t y of hird because there is no arding Indian residential 500 Regional College Council role that the college is to essed. Its functions will center of academic and d which will enhance the 1ese qualities. In terms head would have consider)Ut also those from Howe :w First Narrows cross5ehead center. Eccentric severely jeopardize the N.Von Fioure 6 1968 W.Von N. Von 1972 W. Von N.Von 1976 W.Von STUDENT POOL FOR FRESHMEN tontolus research limited V. A PLAN FOR ACTION A Regional College will be desirable on the North Shore as early as September 1968. This statement i s s u p p o r t e d by an analysis of the growth in numbers of students, their abilities and educational goals; a recognition that the North Shore is a very distinctive section of our Province in terms of the talents and aspirations of the population as a whole; r e c o g n i t i o n that the North Shore is larger than most cities of the province; and by the lack of r e g i o n a 1 college facilities available to students from the North Shore. The Regional College should have a comprehensive program incorporating both the "transfer" facilities for those seeking University degrees and the distinctive college programs leading to the variety of occupations found on the North Shore and in downtown Vancouver. The Regional College should be located in a central. location on a site where it is clearly identifiable and where it can become a truly community college. If the Boards of School Trustees for North and West Vancouver accept these recommendations, certain steps will have to be undertaken. At present the Provincial legislation controlling two-year colleges is embodied in the Public Schools Act. Essentially, school boards wishing to set up a college must ask the permission of the Council of Public Instruction to hold a plebiscite to d e t e r m i n e whether or not the people of the school district concerned favour a college. If the p 1 e b i s c i t e favors a college, a Regional College Council may be formed. The Council then negotiates with the various school boards on the location and financing of the college. Once an agreement has been reached a vote on the local share of the financing of the c o 11 e g e m u s t b e h e 1 d in the participating districts. At present the financing of academic programs in regional colleges is 50 per cent local for capital and operating costs. The n o n - a c a d e m i c programs are eligible for Federal support under the Technical and Vocational Training Assist­ ance Act, 1960, but each college must negotiate its own program with Provincial and Federal authorities to determine which programs qualify. It must be emphasized that the financing of regional colleges is likely to be reviewed. The whole matter of Federal aid to higher education may change as a result of the Bladen Commission Report due in September 1965. Because negotiations will be required in the early stages of planning a college, it is important that a key official be appointed as early as possible. The college principal should be appointed early in the planning stages and to this end he might be appointed to the existing Adult Education Department. If not, a college advisor could be appointed as was done in the West Kootenays and in Vancouver, and the principal appointed late: The recommendatic the Regional College Co undertaken under such l and ( c) finance. principal appointed later. e as early as September .1e growth in numbers of 1 that the North Shore is dents and aspirations of ore is larger than most :e facilities available to gram incorporating both rees and the distinctive d on the North Shore and :ation on a site where it munity college. Vancouver accept these :ar colleges is embodied hing to set up a college n to hold a plebiscite to rict concerned favour a College Council may be ol boards on the location ,n reached a vote on the e 1 d in the participating :ional colleges is 50 per a d e m i c programs are ttional Training Assist­ »rogram with Provincial fy. colleges is likely to be .1cation may change as a 1965. :es of planning a college, s possible. The college and to this end he might If not, a college advisor d in Vancouver, and the -43- The recommendations of this report are obviously only the first stage. When the Regional College Council is established further considerations will have to be undertaken under such headings as (a) staff and organization; (b) physical planning and (c) finance. Each student selecte his parents and returned mittee of researchers in themselves to tabulation . APPENDIX SURVEY TECHNIQUES Data provided by statistical samples can provide quite accurate information on populations where exhaustive interviewing is not feasible. Of course, samples are subject to error: that is, they may not fully represent the universe from which they are drawn. But if the sample is selected according to well-established math­ ematical laws, the error is not only calculable, but it may also be predetermined. An error oft3 per cent is considered more than acceptable in social surveys of this type. The procedures employed to determine the size and composition of the samples that would yield the acceptable level of confidence in the results may be summar­ ized as follows: (a) Determining the most appropriate grade levels for projecting requirements of a regional college for different times in the future. (b) D e t e r m i n i n g the sample sizes which would acceptably limit the error of estimate for the total of North Shore students and for the total students at the sample grade level. (c) Stratifying the sample to guarantee representation in proportion to the number of students at each grade level and the ratio between boys and girls. (d) Selecting a random sample for each class. The following table indicates the grade levels appropriate for projections to 1965, 1968, 1972 and 197 5. Shown on the same table are the number of students in each grade level and the- sample size that would limit the error for the 7,708 stu­ dents in the sample grade levels tot2 per cent. Total Students Grades 1 5 9 12 Total Sample Size 2,413 2,127 1,773 1,395 628 552 460 36 0 7,708 2,000 In order to prevent the samples from being biased in favour of any particular social, economic or academic group, the teachers of each sample class used class rolls and a set of random numbers to select the students to be surveyed. Re p l i e s to questio: cent; Grade 9 - 47. 8 per -45Each student selected was given a questionnaire (attached) to be completed by his parents and returned to school. The questionnaires were designed by a com­ mittee of researchers in order to produce, i n s o f a r as possible, data which lent themselves to tabulation on IBM punchcards. All calculations were verified. accurate information on Of course, samples are .e universe from which well-established mathalso be predetermined. )le in social surveys of nposition of the samples ;sults may be summar- 1rojecting requirements :ably limit the error of :he total students at the roportion to the number 'fS and girls. ,riate for projections to 1e number of students in rror for the 7, 708 stu- tple Size 628 552 460 36 0 ,000 favour of any particular sample class used class > be surveyed. Re p l i e s to questionnaire were Grade 1 - 61.1 per cent; Grade 5 - 70. 2 per cent; Grade 9 - 47. 8 per cent; Grade 12 - 33. 6 per cent. REGIONAL COLLEGE SURVEY The need for a regional college is at present being investigated. In order to determine the characteristics of this college a series of questions has been drawn up to find out the nature of this area and the people within it. As the parent of a child in Grade 1, 5, 9, or 12, you have been selected, at random, to help the college study by answering the following questions. The questions in Part A, those about your neighbourhood, will assist the research team in determining where a college might be located to fit the pattern of family travel now established. The questions in Part B, about your family, will help the team to select the type of programmes that will be suitable for this college bearing in mind the needs and interests of your child and of other children and adults in the community. You, as an individual , will not be identified in any manner. ALL DATA COLLECTED WILL BE TREATED CONFIDENTIALLY. PART A-ABOUT YOUR NEIGHBOURHOOD AND COMMUNITY 1. Your address (nearest 100 block) .............................. ....... .. . 2. Hove you moved in the post five years? Yes.............. 3. If yes, list previous addresses (nearest 100 block). . 4. Are you likely to move to a different home in the next five years? Yes 5. If yes, where?.. 6. List the lost three social visits mode by adult members of your family. From the table below select the type of social relationship involved. (example) No ..................... .............................................. ........................... 0000 Keith Rood 1. 2. . ............................................................... 3. (A) relative (B) present co-worker (C) post co-worl